The ultimate guide to DSG transmissions – What you need to know

September 17, 2020

Most drivers have heard of automatic and manual transmissions, but true enthusiasts know that there are many more options on the market when it comes to transmissions for vehicles.

The direct shift gearbox – also known as the DSG, DCT (dual clutch transmission) gearbox or twin-clutch system – is one specialty transmission type that offers loads of benefits for drivers, whether they’re operating a passenger car, sports car or motorcycle.

DSG transmission can be found on most Volkswagen models, but it’s also been gaining popularity with many other car companies such as Ford, Nissan, Volvo, BMW and more.

But what exactly is a DSG? If you’re new to the world of transmission types, no worries! We’ll help you learn more about the nature of a DSG transmission, how it compares to other common transmission types and the benefits and drawbacks so that you can decide if this car transmission type is right for your needs.

(08) 9240 5449

Make An Enquiry

What is a DSG Transmission?

Born from the exciting world of motorsport, the DSG transmission was made most popular by Volkswagen. It has also become very popular with other car companies, although it goes by different names such as a DCT, PDK, and Powershift.

To put it simply, a DSG is a combination of an automatic transmission and a manual transmission. It gives you the simplicity and comfort of automatic with the control of a manual transmission – the best of both worlds! And the result? An unbelievable driving experience.

How Does a DSG Transmission Work?

The DSG transmission utilises a special DSG gearbox to create smooth, fast gear changes and an improved driving experience. Here’s how it works.

Each DSG gearbox houses two independent units that are connected to the engine – essentially like having two separate gearboxes in one car. The first clutch controls odd gears (1, 3, 5 and sometimes 7), while the second controls the evens (2, 4 and 6). While one gear is operating the vehicle, the second one is preselected and prepared for the next shift in speed. This creates a smooth and nearly seamless shifting experience.

The DSG gearbox is controlled with an electronic transmission control unit as well as a hydraulic unit. It uses sensors to analyse your speed, braking and other information to enhance your driving experience, and it also offers a manual option, allowing you to control gear shifts via a Tiptronic mode or paddles on your steering wheel.

How Does DSG Compare?

Now to answer one of the most important questions you probably have: how does a DSG transmission hold up to other popular transmission types?

DSG vs Automatic Transmission

As far as appearance goes, DSG and automatic cars look very similar inside the cab – there’s no foot clutch pedal to worry about nor any extra levers or systems that you’ll need to use in order to drive. But that’s where the similarities end.

Unlike an automatic vehicle, a car with DSG gives you the option of controlling your gear changes via a shift paddle or Tiptronic system. And because a DSG transmission system uses two clutches in place of a torque converter, not only is shifting smoother and faster, but the car can also be more fuel-efficient than the standard automatic.

DSG vs Standard Manual Transmission

Unlike a standard manual transmission, a DSG utilises two clutch systems rather than a single one. They’re arranged concentrically (one inside of the other) so that only one gear shift is visible.

Despite this similarity in appearance, DSG transmissions use more technology and mechanics than their manual counterparts. With an abundance of sensors, the DSG is able to think for itself and doesn’t need you to control its every move (unless you want to).

On a negative note, DSG systems are heavier than traditional manuals, meaning that they’re ever so slightly less fuel-efficient.

DSG vs CVT Transmission

A continuous variable transmission (or CVT) keeps your engine running at optimal speed by continuously choosing the right gear to keep you in the most fuel-efficient zone.

Like the DSG, a CVT system offers a smooth gear change with an uninterrupted flow of power to the engine. Unlike the DSG, however, a CVT system uses a series of pulleys and belts rather than a fixed number of gears. This means that the DSG won’t always be running at optimal momentum.

DSG vs ZF Transmission

The ZF transmission is designed for maximum fuel efficiency, so it definitely has an edge on the DSG in that regard. However, this means that vehicles with a ZF transmission will often be a bit slower when shifting.

To maximise fuel efficiency, the ZF is also designed to be a lightweight system, and it has the added bonus of being able to jump gears, which a DSG can’t do.

Pros of DSG Transmissions

Want to know all the best parts about a DSG system? Here they are.

Fast Shifting Speeds: Thanks to the ability to preselect gears, the DSG system can execute some lightning-fast gear shifts, especially compared to automatic and standard manual transmissions.
Fuel-Efficient: With no energy lost to the torque converter, the DSG proves to be more fuel-efficient than most automatic cars. In fact, the gearbox wastes so little power that it’s even more efficient than some manual transmissions as well.
Smooth Driving: The DSG sensors know what you’re going to do next, making it a breeze to deliver the correct amount of power and torque so that your drive is smooth and enjoyable.
Optional Control: Feel like putting the pedal to the metal? Take control with the paddle shifts or lever. Want to sit back and enjoy the ride? Let the car drive in automatic so that you don’t have to worry about shifting gears.
More Accessible: With less risk of crunching gears and the addition of automatic options, the DSG is a great choice for drivers who are new to manual driving or who don’t enjoy using a clutch pedal.

Cons of DSG Transmissions

While we do love the DSG transmission, we have to admit it isn’t perfect. The system can be heavier than other gearboxes. Additionally, the intricate system is often a more expensive option and requires upkeep by professionals to ensure it works as it should, making it a bad choice for those who are really on a budget.

Cars with a DSG system are also often prone to jerking forward when going at slow speeds (such as in a parking lot) or when starting up, as the transmission needs to reengage after it’s rested.

How to Care For Your Direct Shift Gearbox Transmission

Just like any transmission, your DSG transmission requires a regular automatic servicing. Because this is one of the more expensive transmissions available, it’s not something you should DIY, and you definitely don’t want an inexperienced technician completing the job, either.

Here at Automatic Transmissions R Us, we offer high-quality service provided only by extremely knowledgeable and well-trained professionals so that you don’t have to worry about a thing. Contact the Auto Trans team today by sending through an enquiry, emailing info@autotransrus.com.au or giving us a call on (08) 9240 5449! We’ll have you back in your car in no time.

      Excellent rating  
 Based on 282 reviews 
    
  
 
 
      I can't thank the team as Transmission R Us enough, they looked at my Ranger with what I thought was a transmission slippage issue but found it was a completely unrelated engine sensor fault. They even showed me where it was and how to change it.
     
   Ben Edwards 
 1 days ago
 
 
 
 
    Automatic Transmissions R Us in Balcatta installed a new clutch in my 2016 VW Golf TSI.  Apparently, this is a tricky installation, but they did a great job, and my car now drives like new.
     
   SOB SOB 
 3 days ago
 
 
 
 
    I must say, I’m not one to often leave reviews, especially when it comes to services like this. However I was really pleasantly surprised with the service here. I’m quite new to the Perth area and had a whining issue with my 2010 rav4, so did some digging for transmission shops around the area, the review of this one definitely stood out and they didn’t disappoint! I went to the Toyota dealership to get the same issue looked at and they just took my 250$ and told me to completely change the Trans and Front diff and quoted me 20k. I came here for a second opinion. I got a call back from cam, who told me after looking at the car it is indeed noisy but it isn’t something that actually deteriorates the life of the car. He proceeded to tell me he has dealt with a lot of the callbacks for this exact model and problem. He told me if I could live with the noise and couldn’t afford a repair he’d recommend I just drive with it. He told me if you put the noisy piece next to one that isn’t noisy you wouldn’t even be able to tell the difference. I really really appreciated the transparency and honesty here, he didn’t try and upsell me or quote me an expensive repair, he just gave me the god honest truth (you can drive with it, if you want the noise gone only way to fix it is to replace it). If there is any other issues with my car at all I’ll be sure to come back here as I was truly impressed by the transparency and quality of service. Many many thanks to the team and especially cam! Bloody legend!
     
   Obey Summer 
 10 days ago
 
 
 
 
    The team at Automatic Transmissions R US were fantastic. Their service was excellent. Pam and the team made the process easy, especially as I was transporting my vehicle by courier. They were able to book my car in for as soon as I could get it delivered. The service team did great work inspecting and then completing the repairs. They kept in contact with any updates and were fast, reliable and reasonably priced.
Thank you Automatic Transmissions R US
     
   Michelle Te Aho-Woodbrook 
 18 days ago
 
 
 
 
    
     
   H S 
 57 days ago
 
 
 
 
    Came here to check my card transmission, very satisfied with the results and they give me good feed back that I need to do, luckily the transmission is no issue so, no charge for that, thanks very much for best service :)
     
   Faisal 
 64 days ago
 
 
 
 
    Ongoing issues with my car others couldn't fix, they sorted first visit, no issues since. Highly recommended 👍👍
     
   markymark9172 
 65 days ago
 
 
 
 
    Cameron and the team are the go to for transmission issues. I could not be happier with the service provided.
     
   Chris Parker 
 93 days ago
 
 
 
 
    I booked the vehicle in for a noise I thought was coming from the gearbox. Graham inspected the vehicle and found it was not a gearbox issue. Graham pointed out other possible faults that could result in the problem i was experiencing. I felt reassured and can highly recommend this repairer who didn't charge me for the diagnosis. Thanks to Cameron and the team at Automatic Transmission R Us a job well done.
     
   George Doneo 
 93 days ago
 
 
 
 
    Trailblazer/ Colorado TC shudder
Had to fight with Holden for many years for a repair for the TC shudder, offered a band aid fix from Holden that failed on two previous occasions.
The team at Transmissions R us were completely honest, as a mechanic in a previous life the explanation of the common problem made sense. (Phoenix Holden constantly denied this issue)
Had the  Transmission  repaired and drove like new, I literally drove the vehicle across Australia towing a boat. After 10 months noticed some slight leaking of ATF on the bell housing. The team repaired the leak that included removal of the Transmission without question.Highly recommend this business.
     
   Darren Ginnane 
 116 days ago